Supreme court on june 25, 2007, ruled 54 that alaskan school officials had not violated a students first. Joseph later recalled that the original suspension was five days, but morse doubled it after he quoted. The supreme court has made it clear that the constitutional rights of students in school setting are not automatically protected in the same way as adults in. Frederick, supreme court ruled that a school could discipline a student for unfurling an offensive banner bong hits 4 jesus across the street from a school event. Frederick, decided by the supreme court last monday, june 25. Every other hearing, from the federal district court, to the court of appeals ruled in favor the principal morse.
If you stop a student from expressing views that advocate drug use, are you violating their right to free speech. Joseph frederick, a student at juneaudouglas high school in juneau, alaska, displayed a banner at a high school event on which was written. Frederick, i hypothesized that readers might be wondering what this high school case has to do with fires mission, which explicitly deals only with higher education and not with high schools. Heres a short summary for those who dont know about morse v. Nearly 60 years ago, the supreme court ruled that public school students do not shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech and expression at the schoolhouse gate. Chief justice roberts, writing for the majority, concluded that the school officials did not violate the first amendment for frederick. Do you agree with the ruling in morse v frederick that the students freedom of speech was not. Principal deborah morse took away the banner and suspended frederick for 10 days.
For forty years, the first amendment has generally protected the right of students to speak on even controversial topics absent evidence that their speech caused substantial disruption within the school. Supreme court case study with argumentative writing on morse v. Search the prezi knowledge base for prezi support, howto articles and videos, and to submit help requests to our team of technical experts. The district court ruled in favor of morse, saying there was no constitutional violation on her part. Frederick said the banner was a nonsensical message and that he intended the banner to proclaim his right to say anything at all. A multimedia judicial archive of the supreme court of the united states. The court will hear argument first today in case 06278, morse vs. Chief justice roberts wrote for the majority and concluded that the school officials did not violate the first amendment. During the olympic torch relay through juneau, joseph frederick, a student, held up a poster at a schoolsupervised event. Argued march 19, 2007decided june 25, 2007 at a schoolsanctioned and schoolsupervised event, petitioner morse, the high school principal, saw students unfurl a banner stating. All you have to do is purchase, download, and print. Frederick by aidan and kennedy the immediate effect of morse v. A high school seniors 14foot banner proclaiming bong hits 4 jesus gave the supreme court a provocative prop for a lively argument monday. The images are figures from the morses electro therapy book figure 12 on page 36 figure 24 on page 48 if we were to include your image, we would be happy to include you in the special thanks in our rolling credits for your participation.
Frederick, involving a high school senior from juneau, alaska, who was suspended for displaying a. Joseph fredrick the student was 18 year old joseph frederick, who was a senior at juneaudouglas high school. In juneau, alaska january 23, 2002, a student from juneau douglas high school, by the name joseph frederick, frederick waited, alongside his fellow classmates for the olympic torch relay runner that would be coming by. Bong hits 4 jesus january 24, 2002 juneau, alaska outcome the superintendent upheld the suspension cornell.
Morse cited the schools antidrug policy, as the banner clearly referenced marijuana. Joseph frederick held up a banner that said bong hits 4 jesus at a school sponsored event. As the olympic torch relay passed outside of joseph fredericks school in juneau, alaska, he unfurled a sign that read bong hits 4 jesus. Joseph frederick p, a public school student, was suspended by the principal deborah morse d for displaying a banner on which was written bong hits 4 jesus, bong being slang for marijuana. The school supervised a field trip for the students to view the relay. Supreme court hears bong hits 4 jesus politics nbc news. At a schoolsupervised event, joseph frederick held up a banner with the message bong hits 4 jesus, a slang reference to marijuana smoking. Constitutional questions breyer, ginsburg, souter, stevens and the lower court dissented analyzing the case under tinker, the lower courts had found no disruption, and therefore no basis for discipline. Audio transcription for oral argument march 19, 2007 in morse v.
Frederick marked the supreme courts first decision addressing the first amendment rights of public school students in nearly twenty years. In this case, a high school senior was suspended for holding up a sign at the olympic torch relay in juneau, alaska, before he had even arrived at school for the day. The court said the phrase bong hits 4 jesus reasonably could be. A case in which the court found an alaska public school principal had the right to suspend a student for holding up a bong hits 4 jesus. Frederick certiorari to the united states court of appeals for the ninth circuit no. The ultimate decision in the supreme court was a 54 vote in favor of principal deborah morse. First amendment by confiscating the prodrug banner and suspend ing frederick. May it please the court, i am shelby simmons, counsel for the petitioner, principal deborah morse. It must have 30% or less of its original natural vegetation. In fridays post about the supreme courts decision in morse v. Rate of religious exemptions for vaccines by new york school by. Frederick 2007 who dissented and what did they think. For the first time in nearly 20 years, the supreme court is poised to address the free speech rights of students. Newcombe1 introduction when justice samuel alito agreed with other members of the supreme court that a school principal.
Principal deborah morse took away the banner and suspended frederick for ten days. She justified her actions by citing the schools policy against the display of material that promotes the use of illegal drugs. Frederick and the regulation of student cyberspeech. New limitations on student speech and the columbine factor caroline b. Principal morse suspended frederick, a high school senior, for displaying a banner which read bong hits 4 jesus. Frederick daniel kilasi this case was a major turning point to student rights. Remote work advice from the largest allremote company. Supreme court on june 25, 2007, ruled 54 that alaskan school officials had not violated a students first amendment freedom of speech rights after suspending him for displaying, at a school event, a banner that was seen as promoting illegal drug use. Mapp v ohio and the the exclusionary rule explained duration.
The event was scheduled to pass along a street in front of juneaudouglas. It found that frederick message was, by his own admission, not political, as was the case in tinker. We would need a photo release signed, which i could send to you, giving us permission to use your image. Frederick was suspended for 10 days because morse believed the sign was promoting the use of illegal drugs, in violation of school policy. June 25, 2007 background joseph frederick, a senior at juneau douglas high school, held up a banner saying. Majority opinion the majority opinion was written by. She justified her actions by citing the schools policy against the display of material that promotes the use of illegal. Frederick law case britannica encyclopedia britannica. The three determinations were that school speech doctrine should apply because. Frederick audio transcription for opinion announcement june 25, 2007 in morse v. The ninth circuit held that principal morses actions violated the 1 st amendment and that the student could sue the principal for damages. Principal morse is appealing the decision of the ninth circuit court which affirmed.
Specialized practice curricular guide for macro social cswe. Teachers and administrators were among the students and were charged with supervising. Deborah morse deborah morse was the principal of juneaudouglas high school. Kreppel ks, caminade c, telfer s, rajerison m, rahalison l, morse a. His principal, deborah morse, said the phrase was a prodrug message that had no place at a schoolsanctioned event. In this paper, we analyze the decision in light of the courts prior decisions since the landmark tinker case, and speculate on the future of students speech cases. June 25, 2007 background joseph frederick, a senior at juneaudouglas high school, held up a banner saying. Frederick 2007 summary the decision in one of the most important student speech cases to reach the court in decades came at the end of last term. Supreme court cases and decisions free speech cases and. The principle of the school, patricia morse, felt the banner had a pro drug message and made him take it down and suspended frederick for 10 days. Frederick lies the first amendment question of whether or not schools can limit students free speech in 2002 joseph frederick, a senior at juneaudouglas high school in juneau, alaska, was suspended for displaying a banner with the phrase bong hits 4.
Frederick, a 54 decision in which chief justice roberts, writing for the majority, decided that a student could be punished for displaying a banner with the words bong hits 4 jesus on a public sidewalk. The supreme court ruled that morse did not violate joseph fredericks first amendment rights. The event in question occurred during normal school hours and was sanctioned by morse as an approved social event at which the districts studentconduct rules expressly applied. School officials, backed by the federal drug czar and two former drug czars, contend that josephs flippant speech was designed to promote illegal drug use, which is contrary to the schools basic educational. Support our response to covid19 your gift will fund our critical work to protect voting rights, demand that vulnerable people in prisons, jails and immigration detention centers be released, and fight to ensure reproductive health care remains open and accessible to all who need it. Making sense of high school speech first amendment. It all started when morse a schoolsupervised event, joseph frederick held up a banner with this message bong hits 4 jesus, this was meant to the marijuana smoking. Criminal justice law rubrics teachers pay teachers. Critically appraised topic manager cat app, available for download on. Frederick, the majority acknowledged that the constitution affords lesser protections to certain types of student speech at school or at schoolsupervised events.
Please pardon our delay in response, we will get back to. He claims he wasnt promoting drug use when he held up the sign. Fraser, supreme court ruled that first amendment did not protect disruptive or offensive student speech. Frederick, concerned the rights of a public school student to unfurl a banner reading bong hits 4 jesus at a schoolsponsored event. Do school authorities violate the free speech clause of the first amendment by restricting student speech at a. Frederick sued and late last year, the ninth circuit court of appeals ruled in his favor. The principal, deb morse, took away the banner and suspended frederick for 10 days saying it promoted illegal drug use.
1578 825 1166 1285 1579 14 7 571 46 1017 669 1578 921 738 657 624 1171 31 1067 1539 100 479 611 1547 1215 356 1052 1248 198 278 599 994 563 733 655 533 732 1363 1418 941 401